RCV vs ACV Roof Coverage
RCV pays what a new roof costs. ACV subtracts depreciation for age and wear, and your policy says which one you have.
Free to compare
Which one you have decides what you actually collect. With RCV, the insurer first cuts a check for the depreciated value, then pays the rest once the roof is replaced and you send proof. With ACV, that second check never comes, so a 15-year-old roof might net only a fraction of what a new one costs. Many insurers also shift coverage from RCV to ACV once the roof passes a certain age, often somewhere around 10 to 20 years. Your declarations page or policy endorsements show which applies and at what age it changes.
What your roof is worth on paper
An ACV roof can leave a wide gap between what you collect and what replacement costs. Comparing policies shows which insurers still write RCV for a roof your roof's age, and what that coverage actually pays.
Does it matter why the roof was damaged
Insurance pays for sudden damage, not for a roof wearing out. A tree limb through the deck, hail that cracks shingles, wind that peels off a section after a storm, those are covered events. A roof that's curling, losing granules, or leaking slowly because it's old and worn is not, even if the insurer would normally offer RCV. That distinction matters more than which coverage type is on your policy, because wear and tear is excluded under both RCV and ACV.
When an adjuster inspects a roof, the first thing they're deciding is which category it falls into. They look for the pattern that matches a storm, like shingles torn in the direction the wind was blowing, or impact marks from hail that are fresh rather than weathered. A roof that's old tends to show even, gradual deterioration across the whole surface instead of damage concentrated where a storm would have hit. If the inspector decides the roof failed from age rather than a covered event, the claim gets denied regardless of whether your policy pays RCV or ACV.
Roof age complicates things beyond the depreciation math. An insurer can look at a 20-year-old roof with storm damage and still pay the claim, since age by itself isn't a reason to deny a covered loss. But that same age makes it harder to prove the damage is from the storm and not years of accumulated wear. It's part of why some insurers decline to write RCV on older roofs at all, or require an inspection before binding a new policy.
If you're filing a claim, photos from before the damage help establish what changed. So does documentation of any prior repairs or a roof certification if one was done when you bought the house or last renewed. None of that changes which coverage your policy lists, but it affects whether the adjuster agrees the damage is covered in the first place, which comes before the RCV or ACV payout is ever calculated.
What happens after you file the claim
Filing a roof claim starts with an inspection, either by an adjuster the insurer sends out or, in some states, a report from a contractor the insurer accepts. They measure the damaged area, check whether it's isolated or spread across the whole roof, and note the roof's current materials and age. That inspection becomes the basis for everything that follows, so what they write down matters as much as what actually happened to the roof.
If the claim is approved, the payout structure depends on what your policy lists. Under RCV, the first check reflects the depreciated value, the same number ACV would have paid. The insurer holds back the depreciation until the roof is actually replaced and you submit the contractor's invoice. Only then does the second check arrive, covering the rest up to your policy limit. Skip the replacement and that second payment never gets sent, so an RCV policy only delivers its full value if the roof gets fixed.
Most policies also set a time limit for claiming that second check, often a year or two from the date of loss. Miss it and the depreciation holdback can be forfeited even though the roof damage was never in question. If a contractor is backed up for months after a big regional storm, it's worth telling the insurer so the deadline can be tracked against what actually happened, rather than assuming it will be extended automatically.
Depreciation itself is calculated using the roof's expected lifespan and its age at the time of loss, not just a flat percentage. A roof rated for 25 years that's 10 years old has lost roughly 40 percent of its value in the insurer's math, though the exact method varies by policy. The adjuster's report usually shows this calculation line by line, and it's worth asking for a copy if it isn't offered, since that document is what the ACV or RCV payout is actually built from.
Check which one applies to you
Find the roof coverage line on your declarations page, and if it names an age cutoff for switching from RCV to ACV, compare that against your roof's actual age.
